The interview room is a sterile shoebox – a grey tomb of a room, walled in by shuttered glass, every surface scrubbed of comfort.
A single bulb is casting stark light over the steel table.
One chair is bolted to the floor.
No mirrors, just the oppressive hush of held breath.
Erica smooths her skirt and sits in the free chair, composed but alert.
She waits.
When the door opens, a young woman steps in, flanked by an officer.
She’s smaller than Erica expected.
Pale.
Pretty, but drawn.
Her eyes are rimmed with sleeplessness and something darker: hopelessness.
As she sits in the other chair, the officer shackles her handcuffed wrists to a steel loop on the table and leaves.
For a long moment, neither of them speaks.
Then: “Hello, Miss Arden,” Erica says, her voice soft, not pitying. “I’m Erica Sinclair. I’m an attorney. You have a benefactor - someone who’s asked me to look into your case.”
Lucy blinks at her, slowly. “A what?”
“A benefactor,” Erica repeats, patient. “Someone who believes you deserve a defense you can trust.”
Lucy frowns, irritated, mistrusting. “Why? Who would do that for me?”
“I can’t tell you who. But they want you to have the defense you need. I’m here to help you.”
The young woman looks at her. She exhales. “Help? You’re a little late, don’t you think?”
There’s no need to argue with her.
In her situation, everybody would be angry.
And scared.
Erica reaches into her bag, pulls out an envelope, unfolds a single page. “This will release your current public defender, Mr. Ullman, and allow me to take over your case.”
Lucy hesitates for only a second.
Then, as much as her restraints allow, she reaches for what must appear like the saving straw and scrawls her name.
Erica watches the signature form slowly, trembling, like a leaf caught in a current.
She tucks the form away.
“Now,” she says, meeting Lucy’s eyes. “I need you to be honest with me. Really honest. No filters, no edits. Tell me everything.”
~~~
“Giovanna Versini and I… we’re friends.” Lucy’s voice is brittle, like a glass already cracked. “Were friends, I guess.”
She shifts in the metal chair, the cuffs clinking softly as she moves.
Across the table, Erica doesn’t speak.
Doesn’t move.
Just watches.
Listens.
She has learned to read a thousand things in silence - body language, breath, hesitation.
Right now, Lucy is trying to hold herself together with words.
“We work at Kimball’s on Rhinelander. Grocery store. Sometimes when we’re not on a closing shift, we… dress up. Hit the bars. Get a couple drinks bought for us.”
Lucy glances up, checking Erica’s face for judgment.
Erica offers none.
Just the same quiet presence.
A still pool.
“It was, what, five weeks ago?” Lucy continues. “We were at The Pelican. That’s where we met him. This guy. Gary Loudon. He was smooth. You know that kind of charm? Not loud. Not creepy. Just - confident. Good-looking. Expensive watch. Perfect teeth.”
She swallows hard, the memory crawling up her throat.
“Before he left, he asked for our numbers. Next day, he texted me. Said he wanted to hang out. Have a good time. Only him and me.”
Her hands, still cuffed, come up to her face.
She wipes her nose with the edge of her sleeve.
The metal bites into her wrists, but she barely flinches.
“I was working, so we met the Friday after. He picked me up in his fancy Mercedes. Leather seats and everything. Took me to this place in Dumbo, like an art gallery with a bar. We had a great time. Felt like…I don’t know. He made me feel like someone.”
Erica nods slightly, an encouragement to continue.
“He asked if I wanted to keep the night going at his place. I said yes.”
Lucy looks her straight in the eye. “Look, I wasn’t stupid. I knew what it meant. And I was okay with it. I wanted to.”
Erica raises her hand gently. “Just to clarify: everything that happened up to that point - was it consensual?”
Lucy nods quickly. “Yeah. Yes. It was.”
“Thank you. Go on, please.”
“His place was incredible. Like, two floors, art everywhere. He said his dad owns half of Brooklyn Heights. Told me he modeled for Calvin Klein in college. I believed him.”
She draws a breath that doesn’t steady her.
“At first, the sex was good. But then… it changed. He started getting rough. Tied my wrists with scarves. At first, I thought, okay, maybe he’s into that. I’ve done that before, right? But then he got really rough. He put me in handcuffs – tight. I told him to stop. I said it hurt.”
Her voice breaks.
Not a sob, just the sound of something internal giving way.
“I told him no. I begged. He smiled like I was a joke.”
Her voice doesn’t crack—it collapses, a sound you can’t rebuild from. “He just kept going, slapped me around. He put this gag in my mouth - pulled the strap really tight… I thought my jaw would break… then he strapped a collar around my neck… so tight… I could hardly breathe.”
Tears run freely as she describes what happened to her till Gary Loudon released her on Sunday afternoon, talks about the torture, the pain, the humiliation.
Her eyes are glazed now, unfocused.
Erica feels her stomach turn, but she keeps her voice steady.
“So, he released you Sunday afternoon.”
“Said I was boring. Threw my clothes at me. Told me to get the hell out.”
Her hands twitch on the table.
She’s shaking now.
“I got on the subway. I was bruised and bloody. A transit cop saw me and called it in. I don’t even remember what I told them. They took me to the hospital.”
“I have seen the photos from the ER,” Erica says. “The police say you wanted to press charges, right? But then you changed your mind.”
Lucy nods.
Her voice drops into something even smaller than a whisper. “The day after I signed the report, he called me. Said his lawyers would destroy me. Said I couldn’t prove anything. Said no one would believe a store girl over someone like him.”
“So, after the police paid him a visit, he threatened you,” Erica states matter-of-factly. “You were scared.”
“I am scared,” she rasps. “Wouldn’t you be scared if you were me?”
Silence.
A beat.
And another.
“Ms. Sinclair, I didn’t want to die. That’s what it felt like - if I pressed charges, I’d lose everything. Then… he started texting Gio. Sent her flowers. Called her baby. She thought it was romantic. I told her what he did to me. She said it didn’t sound like him. She wanted to believe he wasn’t like that.”
Erica leans forward, her voice calm but clear. “And that’s why you went to his apartment?”
Lucy nods, eyes shut now. “I had to stop him. I just wanted to talk. I wanted him to stay away from her. I didn’t want her to go through what I went through.”
“Then what happened?”
“We argued for a moment. He said I was jealous. That I was lying. He got close. I backed up. He grabbed my throat and started choking me. I thought he was going to kill me. I panicked. I pulled the gun. It just… went off.”
Erica breathes out slowly.
She remembers how it had felt when Julio Ramos had come at her with a knife and she had shot him with her father’s .45.
That was only a month ago.
Silence again.
“I didn’t mean to kill him,” she says. “But I wasn’t going to let him strangle me.”
Erica stands and walks to the door. She speaks to the officer posted outside.
“Uncuff her. And get her some water, please. There’s no reason for this to feel like Guantanamo.”
When she turns back, Lucy is staring at her, like she’s not sure if this is real.
Erica’s expression softens - just slightly.
“I believe you.”
And those three words, spoken low but certain, hit harder than any verdict.
~~~
