The Capture of the Good Church Lady (M/F)

[Gaggedcowgirl]

Part One

You are Michelle Raines, a forty-three years old church attendee. You’re very beautiful but polite and down to earth. You have long brunette hair that went just past your shoulders. Your favorite outfit was a satin blouse with a satin fringe scarf under your chin. You wear a long grey skirt and often could be seen wearing two inch heels.

You are what many would describe as the typical church lady. You went every Sunday and gave often. You was also seen as proper in many ways.

To the rest of the congregation, many questioned how you were still single. Sure after the nasty breakup between you and your creepy boyfriend, one could only guess why you weren’t actively putting yourself out there again. Nonetheless, while you may be a bit naive to it, there were many eyes ogling you whenever you came.

One of those pairs of eyes was from Hank. He is a twenty-four year old recent college graduate. You have actually known him for many years as you used to be his Sunday school teacher. You always thought of him highly as he was always spending time with you before and after classes. He was always asking you about your life and reassured you that everything would work out.

What you didn’t know was that behind closed doors, he had subsistent intentions for you. They came from his fantasies of you as his plaything to do with whatever he pleased. And unknown to you, he’s getting ready to make his move…

[radarlove67]

Sounds very interesting, I'll keep an eye out for where the story goes.

[Gaggedcowgirl]

PART TWO

You have just finished up your church service. You are packing up your purse and begin to head out. Just as you’re nearing the exit, you see Hank wave to you. You give him a friendly smile before allowing him to make his way to you.

“Good morning Mrs. Raines!” He says cheerfully. “How are you today? Got any plans?”

“No not at all,” you reply, “I’m just going to be home alone doing some writing.”

Unknown to you, with every word that leaves your lips,Hank is growing more and more excited. You’re going to be alone at home. All he can hope for now is that you stay in that sexy looking outfit.

“Hank?” You ask. He’s been staring for a moment longer than usual. He shakes his head and looks back at you saying, “Aren’t you going to be lonely?”

You laugh and reply, “Maybe, but I actually enjoy my afternoons and evenings being alone. It’s peaceful and people know on Sunday that I won’t be around. I like to relax and read on days like today.”

He nods a bit before saying, “Well it was nice seeing you. I’ll see you later Mrs. Raines.” You smile and wave before going out.

You drive home and once you get back, you immediately kick off your heels revealing your bare feet. You go to the couch and pull out your journal.

As you’re writing, you have no idea that Hank is at the window behind you staring. Well, not just staring. He is imagining you tied up and on your knees. He pictures you with a tight bandana cleave gag and at his mercy.

He takes one more look at his duffel bag filled with supplies. After a deep breath, he smile.

You have no idea…

[Gaggedcowgirl]

You lay back in your couch and set your journal down. Just as you are about to close your eyes, you hear a knock at the door.

“Hmmm,” you wonder aloud, “I wonder who that could be?” You get up from your space and walk over to the front door. Once you open it, you’re surprised to see Hank standing there. He’s dressed in black pants and a black shirt. He’s carrying a backpack with him and he seems to be in quite the cheerful mood.

“Hank?” You ask with a friendly smile, “What are you doing here?” You adjust your scarf, not knowing that Hank was already feeling hard. He smiles shyly at you before asking, “I wanted to know if I could talk to you in private.”

“Oh course, come in,” you reply as you step aside. He comes inside and you close the door behind yourselves. You motion for him to come to the living room and you both sit down on your chairs across from one another.

You smile warmly at him and say, “No need to feel afraid, it’s just you and me. You’re safe here.”

He managed a nervous smile back. After a deep breath, he looks and you and says, “I need help with something… something that has been on my mind for quite a while.”

“Oh? How long do you think? A couple weeks? Maybe a month?” He shakes his head at your answers. After a deep breath, he says, “I think I would push it to be many years of feeling this sort of way.”

“And that is?” You ask hoping he would be able to relax by the manner of your tone. He looks up at you and says, “I have this fantasy… and it involves you.”

[Gaggedcowgirl]

You raise an eyebrow and adjust your satin fringe scarf. You couldn’t lie. You are a bit naive when it comes to fantasizing. Sure, you’ve imagined yourself with someone from church before or having a family but that was about it. Still, you recognize that this was a struggle for Hank so you wanted to be there for him.

“It’s alright,” you say with a small smile, “you can tell me. I won’t tell anyone.”

For but a split second, you can see his eyes change. You can’t put your finger on it but you begin to feel wary. However, you toss it up to nothing and say, “Go ahead Hank. I’m listening.”

He nervously rubs his hands together and looks down. After taking a deep breath, he says, “I fantasize about having you. I fantasize of having you at my mercy. I fantasize of of holding you against your will.”

He pauses allowing the words to settle. You can feel your heart stop. You can feel the hair on the back of your neck stand up and you suddenly feel a bit cold. Clutching your arms around your chest, you lean in and ask, “What do you mean holding me against my will?”

“I want to tie you up, Mrs. Raines!” He blurts out. He throws his hands up and sits back. His eyes close and a sinister smile shows up on his face. “I’ve watched so many movies and read so many books of a pretty woman that is kidnapped. The villains die up their damsel and she becomes a damsel in distress.”

“You want to what?!” You ask unable to hold the horror in your voice. He stands up and smirks down at you. “I want to tie you up. You have such a tight body! And you’re wearing the perfect clothes that make me so hard!”

“Hank!” You gasp but before you can stand up, he puts his hand out forcing you to stay seated. Seeing you still seated, he chuckles and shakes his head. You shake your head and say, “No! I won’t allow this! You need to leave my house now!”

He cackled and mutters, “I’m not going anywhere and neither are you!”

In a sudden rush, he comes down and grabs you by the arms. You let out a shriek but he gives you no time to resist. He turns your around quickly and shoves you on your stomach into the couch!

“Hank! Oh my goodness! What are you doing?!” You try to get up but he holds you down with his knee and you hear him open up his duffel bag. You look back just enough to see him pull out a rope!

“What on-hey!” He grabs you by the wrists and immediately starts to bind your hands behind your back. He works quickly but with careful precision. He winds rope around your delicate wrists before cinching his work down the middle!

“Hank! W-What are you doing?!” You moan. You try to get up but he continues to put his weight on you. You begin to breathe heavily as your heart races. Looking back, you plead, “Hank please! This hurts! Get off-mph!”

His hand claps over your mouth and then using his other, he begins to reach his hand down your skirt!

“Mmf! Gmf mff mn!” Your muffled protests only cause him to grow more excited as he guides his hand over your panties! He laughs and growls in your ear, “Stay down, Mrs. Milf!”

“Milf?! What is that?!” You gasp as his hand leaves your mouth momentarily.

“A milf is a ‘mom-I’d-like-to-fuck!” He explains before clapping your mouth shut again! Your eyes widen in shock and you try to struggle again. “Oh, my little sexy bunny! You’re not wet yet? I’m sure that will change!”

He then let’s go and grabs another rope. You grunt as he begins to tie your elbows together! “Oh! Oh stop! Please! I can’t touch my elbows-ow!”

“I know you can, Mrs. Raines!” He cackles as he binds your elbows together. You grit your teeth and squeeze your eyes shut as you feel him tie the rope off. You finally feel him get up allowing you to try to get up.

You hear him laugh as you stumble and slide down onto the floor. Just as you try to get up, you feel him grab your ankles. “Let’s remove those heels so I can suck on your toes!”

“No!” You squeal in vain as he binds your ankles together. You then feel him remove your heels and throw them off to the side. You moan and cry out, “Help! Someone help!”

[GreyLord]

Great start. I do hope there will be more.

[Gaggedcowgirl]

You suddenly feel him yank off your heels and throw them off to the side. With your bare feet exposed, you feel him grab your ankles and force your feet back so they point to the ceiling. “Oh! Oh my!” You grunt as you squeeze your eyes shut.

You suddenly feel his wet tongue begin to lick around your big toe causing you to moan. “Please! This is so embarrassing!”

“No need to be embarrassed,” you hear him mutter, “it’s only you and me.”

“Please! You can’t do this!” You beg as he continues to pass his tongue all over your feet. As he ignores you, you plead once more, “Stop! I’m begging you! Don’t do this!”

He stops but then you hear him growl, “You talk too much! Time fun the fun part!”

He shoves you down into the floor as he gets up. Just before you can try to move, you feel him plop down on your back! You suddenly see him hold a pair of semen aimed panties near your face. The smell causes you to wrinkle your nose and you mumble, “What’s that for?”

“This is going to go in your saucy mouth, minx!” He cackles. Your eyes widen and you immediately press your lips together and shake your head. He laughs and ups your face. You then feel him pinch harsh forcing your lips to pop open. He jams the panties in your mouth causing you to scream in horror.

“Gmmph!”

Before you can even attempt to spit them out, he yanks a bandana into your mouth and pulls it against the corners of your lips! Your lips are forced to press together over the bandana as he ties a tight knot against the back of your head. “Gmpf!” You squeak out as he forces your hands into a reverse prayer. Your eyes water from the shock and pain but as usual, Hank shows no empathy. Instead, you can only watch as he pulls out another bandana!

[Caesar73]

Great start. I do hope there will be more.

I do too! And I agree!

[Trickster]

Wonderful read! Hope you'll continue the story soon.

[Gaggedcowgirl]

You squeal as he pulls the bandana over your eyes and ties the knot against the back of your head. You try to wriggle free but his hands seize your arms holding you still. You shiver as you feel his nose press into your hair. He then leans to your ear and whispers, “I’m going to have some fun with your beautiful body. I’m going explore your curves and get exactly what I want out of you.”

You can’t help but groan as he grabs your hair and pulls your head back. He claps a hand over your already gagged mouth and then uses his other to grope your boobs!

You feel him let go and begin to wind rope around your body. The rope wind around above and below your boobs. Then in one sharp jerking motion, he pulls the rope tight!

“Mmf!” You grunt as you feel him tie the rope tight. You can also feel your boobs are now more pronounced and stick out more. You suddenly feel Hank grab your scarf collar and pull your face forward. You can’t see his face but you can smell his breath!

You suddenly sense his body stand up and he proceeds to shove your face into his crotch. “Mmph!” You grunt as you begin to struggle to breathe.

You can feel his hard cock through his pants before he lets go and you’re given a moment to breathe. He circles behind you and spanks you causing you to yelp. “Mmph!”

“Good girl! I do love a good proper lady like yourself. It makes for the shock and humiliation all that much more invigorating!”

He then grabs his phone and says, “I’m going to take pictures of you. If you know what’s good for you, you won’t tell a soul. Nod if you understand.”

Weakly you do as you hear his phone snap. He then gets close to your face and mutters, “That’s if I decide to let you go.”

He then pulls off your blindfold and shoves your face in front of you. He gains access and you can only watch helplessly as he goes to your messages.

You look on fearfully as a smile curls on his face. “So… your sister and daughter are coming over?”

[Trickster]

Amazing continuation! Thanks

Just as I said offlist, this is my kind of story! I enjoyed the 2nd person POV and was nicely surprised by the twist at the end. I'm glad there's going to be more to this hot story!

[GreyLord]

You continue to build the intrigue. Well done.

[harveygasson]

Great stuff! Looking forward to more of this.

[Gaggedcowgirl]

You grunt as Hank goes behind you and grabs you by the arms. You feel him reach up and begin to undo the knot to your cleave gag. Just as it gets loose, you breathe a sigh of relief.

That is short lived. He follows it up with yanking hard on the bandana making your cleave gag even tighter than before!

“Grmpf!” You grunt as your eyes squeeze shut in pain. You feel Hank return to in front of you. He tilts your head up with a single finger and smiles at you. “Just knowing how I control your face with my one finger is so invigorating! And believe me, I could feel your relief when I started to undo your gag. I was hoping you would feel that way. Because then when I tighten it, all of your hope evaporates!”

“Yff prfvrt!” You mutter back in muffled words. He chuckles before gently patting your cheek. He grabs you by your fringe scarf and pulls out a rope. It’s time to stand up. We’re going to play a game!”

Without much choice, let alone a say, he forces you on your heels. You watch as he winds the rope around your waist before looping it down the front under your belly button. Then, to your confusion, he leads it under your skirt and guides it through your legs. He lifts your skirt up and has it run along your panties. Before you can guess what’s next, he gives it a harsh yank up!

“Mmmph!!!” You shriek in pain as the rope digs into your crotch! He continues to pull and you can hear his laugh ring in your ears as you howl in pain.

You feel home it off to the loop around your waist and you can’t help but moan. He goes back in front of you and says, “That is known as a crotch tie. I bet a proper church lady like you never would have thought you would have one of those!”

You weakly shake your head but he’s not done. Not even close. You watch him pull out a riding crop and gently put the feathered tip under your chin forcing you to look up.

“You’re going to be a little bunny now. You’re going to hop around in one place. No stopping unless I say so. If you do, then you get punished.”

You blush red in horror and embarrassment. You suddenly feel him tap your panties with the crop before demanding, “Hop up and down!”

[Gaggedcowgirl]

“Mmph!!” You protest but he takes his riding crop and pushes the tip under your chin. You’re forced to look up into his sinister eyes as he looks you up and down.

“Hop or I strip you naked!” With no choice, you do as he says. You begin to jump up and down. Your face turns red as you feel the friction of the rope pressing against your panties. You begin to slow down but he taps your skirt muttering, “Keep going!”

“Plff!” You moan but do as you’re told. As you continue to bounce up and down, you can feel your body tense up. Slowly but surely, you feel your climax coming. You begin to let out muffled grunts as you try to hold back.

Just as you think your body is about to betray you, Hank demands, “Enough!”

You stop panting into your gag. Your body is frustrated but you’re feeling humiliated. Hank goes behind you and holds the riding crop up to your chin forcing you to look up. You feel him clench your butt as he mutters, “Good bunny! I control you now. You will climax when I allow it.”

“Lff mff gff!” You beg but he spanks you in retaliation. “Not on your life!” He sneers before forcing you to the floor facedown. He grabs your legs and pulls them up so your feet are pointed in the air. He then connects a rope to your wrists and ankles. “This is called a hogtie! And whether you like it or not, this will be your punishment!”

“Whmf frff?” You groan as he stands in front of you. He laughs and replies, “That’s for your begging for me to let you go. No, milf, you’re mine now. I’m your teacher now! And this isn’t Sunday school!”

You feel him then take the knot of your gag and undo it. He pulls your cleave gag out but clamps a hand over your mouth keeping the panties in!

“Don’t you dare spit those out or I’ll shove my cock in your mouth! Got it?!” You moan weakly as you nod. You suddenly see him pull out a roll of Microfoam tape. He sits on your back and sticks a part over your mouth. Holding your hair up, he begins to wind it around your face, each pass tighter than the last. When he’s finished, your cheeks are bulging out with how constricting he made it!

“Let’s see you try to preach now!” He cackles before getting off your back. “Mph mrf gmf mpfff mff mrf!” You protest as you roll onto your side.

He sneers before taking the buttons of your blouse and undoing them revealing your lace bra! He then cups your breasts and pulls them out revealing your boobs!

You blush as he pulls his phone out and begins to take pictures of you!

“Gorgeous and hot! The good church lady now exposed and fondled by one of her former students!”

You suddenly hear a knock at your door before it opens! “Michelle! I’m here! Penelope is running late!”

Jenny! Your sister has no idea about your predicament. Hank leaves before hiding behind the door as your sister’s footsteps approach! When she reaches the door, she drops her purse in horror. “Michelle! Oh my gosh!” She runs in but before she can even get to you, Hank comes up from behind and grabs one of her arms! “Oh my goodness!”

“Shhh…” His calm but cold voice mutters as he firmly grabs her other arm. Jenny tries to resist but Hank holds her arms behind her back before taking his right hand and cupping her face. He forces her to look at you before saying, “Lucky me! The MILF has a minx for a sister!”

You moan into your gag as your sister breathes heavily in fear. “Take it easy,” she mumbles softly, “just don’t hurt us!”

“I’ll do whatever I want!” He snaps as he begins to bind her hands behind her back. “Oh! Please! That’s too tight!”

Hank laughs before you see him tie the knot. He then shoves your sister on her knees and circles so he stands in front of her. “A familiar position? Perhaps.”

“You sick pervert,” Jenny mutters back glaring at him. You know in your heart that as defiant and brave as Jenny could be, this behavior was going to get her into serious trouble. Hank chuckles before starting to undo his belt!

Your eyes widen as you realize what his intentions are. Your sister’s face wrinkles up as he reveals his erect cock! “Open wide, Jenny! And if I feel teeth, your sister is getting sold to some very bad men!”

“You can’t do-agk!” Just as her mouth opens, he shoves his cock in her mouth! He takes out a gun and demands, “Pleasure me!”

[Trickster]

Super continuation with the last two parts. Hank's dominant streak has really come through and it's very clear that he's not the Sunday school student he once was. Looking forward to seeing how things play out from here.

[ftlvrguy13]

This is my favorite story I have read in a while and I keep checking back daily for updates. Very hot stuff…

[brittanydeel864]

Lovely story!