LaGuardia greets her with its usual chaos, but this time, no flashing lights part the sea of honking yellow cabs.
Her new driver doesn’t speak.
He just drives, weaving silently through traffic with a grim efficiency that suits the mood.
By the time they pull up in front of 135 West 72nd, the sun has dipped low, casting long shadows between the buildings.
Erica unlocks the door to her apartment and steps inside.
For a moment - just one - she freezes.
Then, Claire’s voice drifts over from the living room.
Gentle. Nurturing.
“I’m sure mommy’s going to be home soon,” she coos, her tone playful and absurdly tender.
Seconds later, the quiet is broken by a blur of fur.
Tiger and Spot come tearing around the corner, meowing and purring, their claws tapping madly on the polished hardwood floor. They skid around her legs in chaotic joy, pawing at her skirt and pulling at the hem like toddlers desperate for attention.
She nearly stumbles and laughs under her breath, dropping her bags to scratch them behind their ears, her hands getting nudged by the tiny furry heads.
Claire appears at the living room door, already gathering her things. “Glad you’re home,” she says, clearly preparing to excuse herself.
As she tries to slip out, Erica stops her.
“Can I talk to you for a minute?”
Claire tilts her head, curious but open, half expecting to be asked if anything of importance had come up at the office while she was away.
“Of course.”
Erica brushes a strand of hair out of her face. She feels the tiredness settling deeper now that she's home, but there’s something she needs to get off her chest.
The walls of her apartment, warm and curated, wrap around her like a well-fitted coat: smooth wood tones, the scent of lavender, the quiet hum of life paused mid-thought.
“I wanted to say I’m sorry,” Erica says. “For dragging you into my personal mess the other day. I know it’s not part of the job description.”
Claire’s brow lifts. “Don’t mention it,” she says easily. “Anything for you.”
“I know,” Erica says, her voice barely above a whisper. “That’s what you always say. I’m still... I don’t know. I’m just feeling bad about it.”
Claire gives a small shrug. “You don’t need to.”
Erica glances around the apartment - her sanctuary, her fortress.
There are maybe three people on Earth she’d ever let into this space after she moved in.
Claire being one of them.
Not just because she’s capable.
But because she has earned her trust and Erica knows that she empathically sees through her armor.
“Don’t,” Claire repeats, gently. She softly lays a hand on Erica’s arm, then, instinctively, withdraws it.
“You know, Erica, if we weren’t boss and employee… we might even be friends.”
She laughs nervously, a touch embarrassed. “That sounded less weird in my head.”
Erica’s breath catches.
Not in surprise, but in recognition.
Because she’s thought the same thing.
Claire is more than capable - she’s steady.
Empathetic.
Present, even when others duck away.
And more than that, she’s someone who has stayed.
Her mind flashes briefly to Andrea Santos, her childhood friend - the only person who truly knows how she was before the world taught her to hide.
Claire could be that too.
Maybe not the same.
But similar.
Real.
Claire sees her.
Not the attorney.
Not the grieving daughter.
Just… her.
“It’s alright, Claire,” Erica says softly. Then, with a slight smile: “Can I treat you to dinner? Just to say thank you. For being there.”
Claire nods. A little too fast, maybe. “Yeah. I’d like that.”
Erica exhales slowly, and the knot in her chest loosens - just a little.
~~~
The kitchen is warm, lit by soft downlights that cast golden reflections off the marble countertops. Outside, the city hums, but up here, everything feels quieter.
Safer.
Claire leans against the counter, arms lightly folded, watching Erica move through the well-appointed space. Erica opens the pantry with purpose, retrieves a jar of peeled San Marzano tomatoes, a small bundle of garlic, and pieces of Serrano bacon.
She looks like someone who has done this dish hundreds of times, going about as if on autopilot.
“I hope you’re hungry,” Erica says over her shoulder.
Claire smiles. “I’m starving. And curious.”
Erica raises an eyebrow. “Curious?”
“I’ve never seen you cook.”
Erica chuckles softly and sets a pan on the stove. “That’s because I usually don’t have visitors over.”
Soon, the scent of garlic sizzling in olive oil along with chopped onions and browned Serrano bits fills the kitchen. Erica pours in the tomatoes, crushing them by hand as they fall. She stirs the sauce, then checks the spaghetti simmering on the other burner. As the pasta reaches near perfection, she scoops them into the sauce to finish them off - low and steady, like her voice when she speaks again.
“My father told me this was something my mother used to make,” she says quietly.
Erica stirs the sauce like it is muscle memory. “Simple. Rib-sticking. Something you could eat even when the world felt like it was falling apart.”
Claire looks up, surprised by the softness in Erica’s tone.
“I never knew her,” Erica adds, almost as an afterthought. “She died when I was two.”
The words hang in the air, suspended like steam over the stove.
Claire doesn’t speak.
She doesn’t need to.
Her stillness is comforting.
Grounding.
Erica pauses at the stove, spoon in hand. Realizing what she’s said, she draws a quick breath and lets it out slowly. “Sorry. That probably sounded more sentimental than I meant it to.”
“No, it didn’t.” Claire says gently. “It sounded real.”
Erica nods once and reaches for the shredded mix of Mozzarella and Parmigiano. She turns back to the deep pan, her movements quieter now. More deliberate.
~~~
With the cooking done, the two women settle on the couch, bowls in hand, glasses of Nero d’Avola catching the warm light. The wine is bold and earthy, like the dish itself.
A pairing meant to comfort.
Tiger and Spot tumble across the carpet, pawing at each other and climbing over their jungle gym like tiny gladiators. Their playful chaos adds a low background hum, a kind of domestic punctuation.
“This is delicious,” Claire says, mouth half-full. “I’ll have to come over more often to sample your cuisine.”
Erica laughs softly. “Thanks for the compliment. Actually, I enjoy cooking.”
Claire takes a sip of wine, then looks at her carefully over the rim of her glass.
“Can I ask you something? Is everything okay with… your father?”
The air stills slightly.
Erica sets her bowl down on the table, wipes her mouth with the corner of a napkin. Then she nods.
“Yes. It’s… settled.” She glances at Claire, searching her face for something - doubt, maybe, or worry.
But there’s none.
Only quiet attention.
And something in that gaze disarms her.
She sits back into the couch, letting the silence stretch. It feels good - strangely good - to not explain everything. To not perform strength.
Claire doesn’t need her to explain.
Or pretend.
She just listens.
And somehow, that’s the part Erica didn’t know she needed.
“I didn’t realize how much I missed just… this,” Erica says, her voice lower now. “Sharing space with someone who doesn’t judge. Who’s just here.”
Claire says nothing.
But her small smile says enough.
They don’t fill the silence. They let it settle, soft as a blanket. Some truths need no narration.
~~~
Later, at the door, Claire shrugs into her coat, wine still warm in her chest. She picks up her tote bag, turning to leave.
“Thanks again,” she says softly. “Not just for dinner. For letting me in a little.”
“It’s not something I do easily,” Erica admits.
“I know.”
They stand by the door for a long moment.
Then, instinctively, they step toward each other… and hug.
It’s brief.
Gentle.
No performance, no drama.
Just a brief moment of emotional warmth shared between two people who have just gotten to know each other better.
Their arms linger for a moment too long before they pull back at the same time - sudden, awkward, unsure.
They both half-smile.
Not embarrassed.
But maybe surprised.
“Good night, Erica,” Claire says.
Erica takes back half a pace. “Good night. I’ll see you at the office in the morning.”
Claire steps into the hallway, and Erica closes the door behind her with a soft finality.
~~~
